Mail on Mac: no Signed/Lock icons for one account after "New Identity Preference" with an FNMT certificate
Hi all,
I'm trying to digitally sign mail (cryptographic signature, not a text signature) from carlos@griell.com in Mail, using a personal FNMT certificate. The signing controls do not appear for that account.
Setup: macOS 27.0 Beta (26A5353q), Mail 16.0 (3891.100.17.1.3). In Keychain Access (System keychain), the certificate is shown as valid until 31 Dec 2028, with the imported private key listed under it.
What I see
1. In a new message with From set to cgriell@northernrock.org, an account where I added an older certificate years ago (now expired), the header shows an open lock and a grey signing icon with an X on the right.
2. With From set to carlos@griell.com, neither icon appears.
What I did
Following Apple's help, I selected the FNMT certificate in Keychain Access, chose New Identity Preference, entered carlos@griell.com and clicked Add. The window closes with no message or error.
https://support.apple.com/guide/mail/use-personal-certificates-mlhlp1179/mac
Back in Mail, a new message from carlos@griell.com still shows no icons. Switching From to cgriell@northernrock.org shows them; switching back to carlos@griell.com hides them.
Other notes
Sectigo's instructions say to use "Customize" in the header to add Signed and Lock. In my Mail, I cannot find that selector. View offers Cc, Bcc, Reply-To and Priority Field, but nothing for signing. I don't know which Mail version that advice applies to:
I also found a similar report, with no resolution in the thread:
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/255488617
Questions
• How can I check whether the identity preference was actually saved, and where it is stored?
• What certificate requirements does Mail check before showing the signing controls, particularly the email address and permitted uses? Could an unsuitable certificate explain the absence of the icons, even after creating an identity preference?
• Has the header/Customize behaviour changed between Mail versions?
I haven't established whether this is a bug or a certificate/configuration issue. Any pointers would be appreciated.
Thanks.
MacBook Air (M4, 2025)